The Scribe Method The Best Way to Write and Publish Your Non-Fiction Book
How To Pick The Right Book Publishing Options
The world of book publishing is complex and often confusing, especially for first-time authors. With so much outdated advice circulating, it can be challenging to determine the best publishing path for your book. Should you self-publish? Should you pursue a traditional publishing deal? What about hybrid publishing?
This guide will break down the three main publishing options—traditional, self, and hybrid publishing—so you can make an informed decision based on your goals and needs.
Understanding the Book Publishing Landscape
Publishing has evolved dramatically over the past decade. While traditional publishing once dominated the industry, self-publishing has become a viable and often preferable alternative. Unfortunately, many guides on publishing focus on novelists or hobbyist writers, leaving professionals, entrepreneurs, and business leaders with little relevant information. If you’re looking to publish a business or personal development book, you need a different perspective.
Let’s explore the three main publishing options and their pros and cons.
Traditional Publishing
What Is Traditional Publishing?
Traditional publishing involves securing a book agent who pitches your book to major publishing houses (e.g., HarperCollins, Simon & Schuster). If a publisher offers you a deal, they purchase the print license to your book and provide an advance against royalties. They handle the publishing and distribution process, but you have little control over your book’s creative direction or marketing.
Pros of Traditional Publishing
- Monetary advance: You receive an upfront payment before your book is published.
- Potential for media coverage: Traditional publishers have connections that may increase your book’s exposure.
- Prestige and bookstore placement: Traditional publishing still holds a level of credibility, and books may be placed in bookstores.
Cons of Traditional Publishing
- Difficult to secure a deal: Less than 1% of book proposals are accepted.
- Loss of ownership: The publisher controls the print license and many creative decisions.
- Limited financial upside: Royalty rates are low—typically 15% for hardcover, 7.5% for trade paperback, and 5% for mass market books.
- Lack of marketing support: Authors are often responsible for their own book promotion.
- Long publishing timeline: It can take 12 to 36 months to publish your book.
Should You Choose Traditional Publishing?
If you already have a large, engaged audience (e.g., 25,000+ guaranteed book buyers), a traditional publisher may offer you a significant advance. Otherwise, getting a deal is difficult, and self-publishing might be a better option.
Self-Publishing
What Is Self-Publishing?
Self-publishing allows authors to retain full control of their book. You are responsible for writing, editing, designing, publishing, and marketing your book. While it requires more effort, self-publishing offers significant advantages, particularly for professionals who want to establish authority or grow their business.
Pros of Self-Publishing
- Full ownership: You retain all rights and control over pricing, design, and content.
- Higher royalties: You keep a much larger percentage of sales—often 70% from platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing.
- Faster publishing: Books can be published in a matter of weeks or months.
- No gatekeepers: You don’t need approval from agents or publishers.
- Ideal for entrepreneurs: Business owners can use their books as lead generators, marketing tools, and credibility builders.
Cons of Self-Publishing
- Upfront costs: You must invest in editing, cover design, and marketing.
- Marketing responsibility: You are responsible for promoting your book.
- Limited bookstore placement: Self-published books are rarely stocked in physical stores.
Should You Choose Self-Publishing?
If you want to retain ownership, maximize profits, and publish on your own timeline, self-publishing is the best option. It’s especially useful for entrepreneurs, coaches, consultants, and professionals who want to leverage their book for business growth.
Hybrid Publishing
What Is Hybrid Publishing?
Hybrid publishing combines elements of traditional and self-publishing. Typically, authors pay for publishing services upfront while the company manages production and distribution.
Why Hybrid Publishing Is Often the Worst Option
- High upfront costs: Many hybrid publishers charge thousands of dollars without guaranteeing quality.
- Limited control: Authors may lose rights or have limited say in design and marketing.
- Questionable reputation: Many hybrid publishers lack credibility, making it harder to market your book.
Should You Choose Hybrid Publishing?
In most cases, hybrid publishing is not a good investment. Authors often pay traditional publishing prices while receiving lower-quality services. If you’re considering hybrid publishing, do thorough research and verify the company’s track record.
Conclusion: Which Publishing Option Is Right for You?
- If you have a large audience and can secure a significant advance, traditional publishing may be a good choice.
- If you want full control, higher profits, and a faster publishing timeline, self-publishing is the best option.
- If you’re considering hybrid publishing, be cautious and research thoroughly.
Take the Next Step
For a more in-depth guide to book publishing, check out the free online copy of The Scribe Method here.
Prefer a hard copy? Order your copy of The Scribe Method here and start your publishing journey today!